Selecting the proper roofing material is not only an issue of appearance — it’s also a matter of performance, protection and long-term value. In San Diego County, where the climate bounces from sun-scorched inland summers to salty ocean air along the coast, your roof has to do more than just cover your home. It has to resist heat, deal with coastal weather, and last for decades.
Here at JCIS Roofing, tile and asphalt shingles are two types of roofing we frequently install and repair. But which is the better option for homeowners in San Diego?
In this post we’ll explain the pros, cons and critical reasoning behind tile vs. shingle roofing; helping you to make the smartest decision, for both your home and your wallet.
The Short Answer (If You’re In A Hurry):
Opt for Tile for durability, Mediterranean aesthetics and top-of-the-line performance in heat and coastal conditions.
Select Shingles if you want an affordable, adaptable roofing option that is simple to install and maintain.
However, the best option isn’t the same for everyone. Let’s dig deeper.
Asphalt Shingles: Cheap and Easy and Everywhere
Pros:
- Affordable cosmetics – Ideal for the home-body that needs first-rate features without the high price.
- Simple to install and fix – Reduced labor costs and faster turnaround.
- Styles – Modern shingles can replicate wood, slate or tile.
NOTE Savings: Lightweight – No structural reinforcement needed
Cons:
- Lifespan – Usually 20–30 years – Shorter.
- Less heat resistant – They can break down more quickly under a scorching sun.
- More susceptible to wind uplift – Particularly in older or poorly attached roofs.
Asphalt shingles are the most popular option among American homes, and deservedly so. They’re low-cost, available in an array of colors and textures, and work with most home styles.
In San Diego’s inland communities, such as Escondido, Vista or El Cajon, shingles work well — but the sun is unrelenting. Granule loss, warping and shortened lifespan may occur with prolonged UV exposure. Should you go with shingles, choose cool roof rated options with reflective properties to help deal with the heat.
Long-Lasting, Beautiful and Built for the Southwest: Tile Roofing
Pros:
- Super Strong – With correct maintenance can endure 50+ years.
- Heat Resilient — Reflects more sunlight and insulates better than shingles.
- Fabulous in coastal air – Clay and concrete don’t rot like metal.
- Chic – Favoured for Spanish, Mediterranean, and Modern homes.
Cons:
- Higher initial investment – The materials and labor are more expensive.
- Heavy – May need added structural support.
- Fragile – Tiles can break under foot traffic or impact.
Tile roofing—particularly clay or concrete tile—is perfect for San Diego’s coastal and inland neighborhoods. It holds up to both searing heat and the salt air well, so it is popular in areas like Carlsbad, Del Mar and La Jolla.
Although the initial installation cost can be higher with tile roofs, they often prove to be more cost-effective long-term due to their longevity and energy efficiency.
Performance Comparison: How They Handle San Diego’s Conditions
(Make a table for this please)
| Feature | Asphalt Shingles | Tile Roofing |
| Lifespan | 20–30 years | 50+ years |
| Initial Cost | $$ | $$$$ |
| Maintenance | Low | Moderate |
| Sun Resistance | Moderate (unless cool-rated) | Excellent |
| Wind Resistance | Moderate | High |
| Coastal Durability | Fair | Excellent |
| Aesthetic Options | Many | Classic Mediterranean |
| Structural Load | Lightweight | Heavy – may need reinforcement |
Environmental Impact: Choosing the Greener Roof
Tile roofs usually take the crown for sustainability. Concrete and clay tiles are produced from natural, recyclable materials, and their durability also results in less waste. They also provide better insulation, minimizing excessive air conditioning.
That said, asphalt shingles have been upgraded over time. The roofing industry is also now replete with cool roof technology and recyclable options, though most shingles still end up in landfills when they are replaced.
If sustainability is important to you, however, tile roofing is probably the more long-term choice.
Maintenance and Repairs: What You Should Know
Shingle Roofs: Less expensive and easier to repair. Each of them can be replaced individually without too much trouble. But they’re also more susceptible to problems such as curling, granule loss and algae growth.
Tile Roofs: Tiles are durable by themselves but can break from being stepped on or from debris falling on them. Repairs are labor-intensive, especially if underlayment is involved, but luckily they’re not often necessary.
At JCIS Roofing not only do we offer maintenance services for both types of roofing, but we can also help you come up with a pro-active plan for maximizing the life of your roof—regardless of materials.
What About Insurance?
Tile roofing is more durable and fire resistant, making it a popular choice in regions subject to high winds or wildfires, which means insurance companies often favor it. Depending on your circumstances, you might even qualify for lower premiums. But because the installation cost is higher, the savings may even out eventually.
Always consult your homeowner’s insurance provider to understand how your choice of roofing might impact coverage or rates.
So… Which One Should You Choose?
You Should Choose: Tile Roofing
If:
You are located near the coast or in high-sun areas.
You plan to live in your home for the long haul.
You’re looking for an upscale, tough, and low-maintenance choice.
You care about energy efficiency and sustainability.
You Should Choose: Asphalt Shingles
If:
You’re doing so on a tighter budget but are still after good performance.
Your house can’t bear the weight of tile without upgrades.
You need a quicker installation process or intend to sell quickly.
Ultimately, the best roofing type for you will depend on your home, your budget, and how long you plan to keep the roof. That’s why we always suggest that a licensed roofing contractor like JCIS Roofing inspect your roof and explain your options in detail.
JCIS ROOFING GUIDE YOU TO A RIGHT CHOICE.
Well, at JCIS Roofing, we provide asphalt shingle tile roof installation, repair, and replacement throughout San Diego County. So whether it’s affordability, durability or long-term value you’re seeking, you can find the roofing system that works perfectly for your individual home and climate.